Title: FA bids limitation rule Post by: PacersGM on October 08, 2007, 11:02:55 AM i posted this already last season, but as it seems some guys still haven´t noticed it.
i will only insert the first 5 bids of each possible bid( Max, MLE, LLE and min). After watching the first FA bids already exceeding that number, i will make it very obvious. I will only insert the first 5 bids of MLE, LLE, min and max bids that aren´t bids on your own players. You can of course make as many offers as you want for your own player but the rest will be limited. Title: Re: FA bids limitation rule Post by: NetsGM on October 08, 2007, 11:04:48 AM 5 per day or 5 total?
Title: Re: FA bids limitation rule Post by: BlazersGM on October 08, 2007, 11:23:53 AM If we dont use MLE/LLE then we can make 15 offers to other players no ?
Title: Re: FA bids limitation rule Post by: PacersGM on October 08, 2007, 11:34:07 AM 5 per day. since most FA will decide in the first 2 days it won´t make it too different if i allow 5 total per day or 5 extra per day.
Title: Re: FA bids limitation rule Post by: PacersGM on October 08, 2007, 11:37:48 AM If we dont use MLE/LLE then we can make 15 offers to other players no ? No,i won´t allow that. i can´t see a difference between 15 max offers and 15 MLE offers. Title: Re: FA bids limitation rule Post by: WizardsGM on October 08, 2007, 11:44:21 AM Now this doesnt apply to me, but I am curious to know what your ruling would be on the following:
A team is 25mil under the cap, and they would like to offer to 2 max guys and then 10 other guys in the 3-7mil range. Would you allow that, or no because he is offering to 10 other guys and not 5? Title: Re: FA bids limitation rule Post by: CelticsGM on October 08, 2007, 11:49:31 AM well, if you have cap space obviously EVERY offer has to be entered
Anything else would be ridiculous ... :bash: Title: Re: FA bids limitation rule Post by: WizardsGM on October 08, 2007, 11:56:36 AM well, if you have cap space obviously EVERY offer has to be entered Anything else would be ridiculous ... :bash: Well this is what I am trying to clear up since apparently he is putting a cap on MAX offers (which is rediculous as far as I'm concerned, how hard is it to hit the MAX BID button? but that's neither here nor there). Title: Re: FA bids limitation rule Post by: CelticsGM on October 08, 2007, 11:58:19 AM Well this is what I am trying to clear up since apparently he is putting a cap on MAX offers (which is rediculous as far as I'm concerned, how hard is it to hit the MAX BID button? but that's neither here nor there). :lmao: :lmao: :lmao: :lmao: :lmao: :lmao: :lmao: :lmao: :lmao: :lmao: Title: Re: FA bids limitation rule Post by: Str8westcoasta on October 08, 2007, 05:32:12 PM Well this is what I am trying to clear up since apparently he is putting a cap on MAX offers (which is rediculous as far as I'm concerned, how hard is it to hit the MAX BID button? but that's neither here nor there). :lmao: :lmao: :lmao: :lmao: :lmao: :lmao: :lmao: :lmao: :lmao: :lmao: I'll see your: :lmao: :lmao: :lmao: :lmao: :lmao: :lmao: :lmao: :lmao: :lmao: :lmao: and raise you 1 :lmao: Title: Re: FA bids limitation rule Post by: CelticsGM on October 08, 2007, 06:01:40 PM ok, let's get this back to a reasonable level.
i don't want the commissioner feel he's treaded poorly again, I think his request has a valid point. There's nothing worse than submitting offers for superstars like Dwight, entering 4 max offers, three more for 10+ million, and 7 MLEs and 3 LLEs !!! Please guys, be a bit realistic, and don't make it deliberately tough on the simmer. but there's no point in rejecting any offer if you got cap space. None. That's the main reason to go below the cap, to make offers, and there shouldn't be a limit on the number of those. Commissioner, let's make a deal: WE THE GMs OF SSBA WILL MAKE IT EASIER FOR YOU, SUBMITTING MOSTLY INTELLIGENT OFFERS ... AND YOU MAKE IT EASIER ON US TOO, ACCEPT QUALITY OFFERS, DON'T PLAY LAWYER BUT RATHER MEDIATOR SOMETIMES. AND LISTEN TO THE PEOPLE'S VOICE EVERY NOW AND THEN And the SSBA world will be a happier place again ... :tup: Title: Re: FA bids limitation rule Post by: Str8westcoasta on October 08, 2007, 06:06:52 PM ok, let's get this back to a reasonable level. i don't want the commissioner feel he's treaded poorly again, I think his request has a valid point. There's nothing worse than submitting offers for superstars like Dwight, entering 4 max offers, three more for 10+ million, and 7 MLEs and 3 LLEs !!! Please guys, be a bit realistic, and don't make it deliberately tough on the simmer. but there's no point in rejecting any offer if you got cap space. None. That's the main reason to go below the cap, to make offers, and there shouldn't be a limit on the number of those. Commissioner, let's make a deal: WE THE GMs OF SSBA WILL MAKE IT EASIER FOR YOU, SUBMITTING MOSTLY INTELLIGENT OFFERS ... AND YOU MAKE IT EASIER ON US TOO, ACCEPT QUALITY OFFERS, DON'T PLAY LAWYER BUT RATHER MEDIATOR SOMETIMES. AND LISTEN TO THE PEOPLE'S VOICE EVERY NOW AND THEN And the SSBA world will be a happier place again ... :tup: I'd like to tag an ammendment on to that proposal: "We make it easier blah, blah ,blah... James Ray for Joe Dumars!" Get's my vote! Title: Re: FA bids limitation rule Post by: SonicsGM on October 08, 2007, 11:20:57 PM My two cents...
Yes, there should be a limit on MLE and LLE and MIN offers...that's understandable. But, if there are several players worth max contracts, and you can offer a max contract, you should be able to offer it to any and all players that you seem fit. You shouldn't have to limit your offers to five players...all that does it open the door for others to land the guys that you may be able to sign. On another note, if you can sign 2 max players, then the thought of capping offers is even dumber. Title: Re: FA bids limitation rule Post by: NetsGM on October 09, 2007, 12:25:52 AM limits should only be on exceptions. They should not be on offers made with cap space (either custom offers or max offers). Doing so would be a huge mistake IMO. 90% of people you offer max to will take their previous teams max offer. You should absolutely have full flexibility to use your cap space.
The 5-per-exception rule was to prevent people from going crazy and offering half the league their MLE. It should not reduce the value of cap space. Title: Re: FA bids limitation rule Post by: SonicsGM on October 09, 2007, 02:08:40 AM limits should only be on exceptions. They should not be on offers made with cap space (either custom offers or max offers). Doing so would be a huge mistake IMO. 90% of people you offer max to will take their previous teams max offer. You should absolutely have full flexibility to use your cap space. The 5-per-exception rule was to prevent people from going crazy and offering half the league their MLE. It should not reduce the value of cap space. I agree completely Title: Re: FA bids limitation rule Post by: PacersGM on October 09, 2007, 03:34:16 AM well teams with capspace have way more options than anyone else. I never posted i would limit their midrange offers or something like that. Teams with capspace are normally offering the most thought trough bids. The risk to loose all the capspace on people that aren´t worth the money prevent them from doing silly offers.
I have no problem to allow more offers to teams with capspace. In most FA we usually have maybe 3 or 4 guys worth max. |