SSBA

Archive => Processed Trades => Topic started by: MagicGM on June 01, 2005, 10:07:48 AM



Title: Magic-Memphis - Waiting 41
Post by: MagicGM on June 01, 2005, 10:07:48 AM
Magic sends:
rashard lewis

for

Ray allen
1st rounder (memphis, this year)

magic sends

bruce bowen
joe johnson

for

Shandon Anderson


Title: Magic-Memphis - Waiting 41
Post by: NetsGM on June 01, 2005, 10:09:02 AM
please specify the year and team the first rounder is coming from.


Title: deal
Post by: GrizzliesGM on June 01, 2005, 10:10:48 AM
First I will cut Shammond Williams

I accept but I believe under rules the deal must be...


Rashard Lewis
for
Ray Allen


and

Bruce Bowen
Joe Johnson
for
Shandon Anderson
1st rounder in 08


Title: Magic-Memphis - Waiting 41
Post by: MagicGM on June 01, 2005, 10:11:40 AM
the 2nd part of the deal won't be done until sim 4 I believe...


Title: nets
Post by: GrizzliesGM on June 01, 2005, 10:14:27 AM
By the way Nets, do you think you could process this trade soon and update the rosters because these are a lot of players being exchanged so i would like to see what it looks like.

Thanks.


Title: Magic-Memphis - Waiting 41
Post by: NetsGM on June 01, 2005, 10:14:43 AM
A first rounder can be traded with Ray Allen.  It's just another player that can't be.

And yes, Joe Johnson cannot be traded until after sim 4.

And no, the rosters won't be updated.  I only update rosters when a simulation is run.  But it's really just 1 player from each team switching teams at this point.


Title: Magic-Memphis - Waiting 41
Post by: MagicGM on June 01, 2005, 10:17:32 AM
the 1st rounder would be the grizzlies' in '08


Title: ok
Post by: GrizzliesGM on June 01, 2005, 10:17:50 AM
okay, so the only change for this sim will be...

grizz. get lewis and magic get allen?


Title: Magic-Memphis - Waiting 41
Post by: MagicGM on June 01, 2005, 10:21:31 AM
yes.. and probably your pick :D


Title: Magic-Memphis - Waiting 41
Post by: NetsGM on June 01, 2005, 10:22:03 AM
Magic, Yeah, I saw that you edited your first post.  Sorry about that.

Grizz: Lewis, Allen and the first rounder can switch teams now.  Everything else has to wait until sunday.


Title: Magic-Memphis - Waiting 41
Post by: MagicGM on June 01, 2005, 10:22:59 AM
Quote from: NetsGM
Magic, Yeah, I saw that you edited your first post.  Sorry about that.

Grizz: Lewis, Allen and the first rounder can switch teams now.  Everything else has to wait until sunday.


I edited it after you replied to it :D


Title: Re: deal
Post by: CelticsGM on June 01, 2005, 10:33:37 AM
Quote from: GrizzliesGM
First I will cut Shammond Williams

I accept but I believe under rules the deal must be...


Rashard Lewis
for
Ray Allen


and

Bruce Bowen
Joe Johnson
for
Shandon Anderson
1st rounder in 08

Another blockbuster in the making

And Memphis get's better AGAIN, being able to move Richardson back to his natural SG pos and starting Lewis, a much better defender than Ray at SF and ADDITIONALLY getting a huge talent in Johnson. They lose cap flexibility in Anderson but with that team ... WHO CARES ?

So why would the Magic do this. Well, hmmm, the lose their starter AND backup at SF for a guy who can't play SF and an expiring which won't help them since they are way over the cap. They are now stuck with Mobley(30), Allen(30), BigDog(32) and Anderson(31) at SF&SG. Any they won't have any cap space until 2011.


this trading season is really getting worse by the minute ...


Title: Magic-Memphis - Waiting 41
Post by: NetsGM on June 01, 2005, 10:36:46 AM
Quote
And Memphis get's better AGAIN, being able to move Richardson back to his natural SG pos and starting Lewis


Just a side note, Richardson's defense actually got better with his move to SF.


Title: Magic-Memphis - Waiting 41
Post by: SixersGM on June 01, 2005, 10:46:48 AM
Wowowee..


Title: Magic-Memphis - Waiting 41
Post by: MagicGM on June 01, 2005, 10:51:36 AM
albeit this deal is questionable as of now, Ray is actually a better scorer and I also get 2 good trade assets in Shandon Anderson and their 1st rounder.


Title: Magic-Memphis - Waiting 41
Post by: GoldenStateGM on June 01, 2005, 10:55:31 AM
I would not call Johnson a huge talent...  He is less then mediocre in this league, the way his TC's have gone.
Magic can plug Josh Howard back into his natural sf spot, and he is probably an A- defender there.
Next to Jason Kidd, Ray Ray's lack of defense will be partially compensated for, I would think.
The Magic are now an incredible offensive team.  Kidd, Ray Allen, and Howard are very nice combo.

Memphis improved their defense quite a bit, but JRich will move back to SG, bringing his defense down to a B+.  Still, an overall defensive upgrade, but I think Lewis and JRich are both very good post defenders, so they may be vulnerable to outside shooting teams.  Only time will tell.

And Anderson's expiring contract may come in handy as the trading deadline approaches...

I do give the edge to Memphis, though, depending upon how that picks works out.  But Rashard's production never matched his Detroit??? days.  Ray is a much better 1st offensive option.  Could easily go the other way, depending upon how the teams mesh...


Title: now
Post by: GrizzliesGM on June 01, 2005, 11:08:48 AM
Now that the trade has been finalized I will give my reasons. While Allen can score well he is a big liability on defense and especially turnovers. Defense and Turnover are probably the two most important reasons why I won last season. Ray Allen is declining while Lewis is pretty much who he is and will stay that way for some years to come. My 1rst rounder would not be anything if I win as much as I think I will. Cap space is npt an issue and so trading anderson for something usefull is key. I like how my team gets bigger. By the way, I did notice that Richardson is really a SF in this game rather than a SG and so don't be suprized if Lewis ends up playing shooting guard.


Title: Magic-Memphis - Waiting 41
Post by: CelticsGM on June 01, 2005, 12:00:27 PM
Quote from: MagicGM
albeit this deal is questionable as of now, Ray is actually a better scorer and I also get 2 good trade assets in Shandon Anderson and their 1st rounder.

While I'm sure there are reasons to do this trade for you, I think you'Re misled here: Ray is a better scorer but also 4 years older and on your books for 5 more years. He'll need crutches by then.

Let's see how a 31 year old exipring will bring you more than a 24yr old with better values. You need to trade it as it won't bring you anything if you let it expire.

And the pick, well I'll likely pick right behind you as I might get the first in the 2nd round ...


Title: Magic-Memphis - Waiting 41
Post by: GoldenStateGM on June 01, 2005, 12:07:43 PM
Quote from: CelticsGM

And the pick, well I'll likely pick right behind you as I might get the first in the 2nd round ...

That will depend on the Memphis frontcourt.
Wallace is now doing to Memphis what he did to me last year, killing the offense, 41% field and 51% from the line.  With Biedrins at 43% and 58% line, the frontcourt is having scoring difficulties.
Of course, I did trade those two players to the Grizz, to help them on their way to a championship, so I could be a little bitter... j/k   :D
But seriously, one of those two will have to step up their shooting soon.
Last year, Ben stepped it up after I traded him.  He was hitting 38% about 3 sims into the season, and ended the season at 44%, a huge jump.


Title: Magic-Memphis - Waiting 41
Post by: KingsGM-old on June 01, 2005, 04:36:04 PM
it seems like magicGM is making a hard push for the oldest starting five in the league...that's just stupid move, trading away 26 year old star for the 30 year old guard with bad defense and horrible contract.

 grizzlies got lucky again IMO

p.s. but that wont be enough against the Kings of the league :)  :wink:


Title: Magic-Memphis - Waiting 41
Post by: CelticsGM on June 01, 2005, 04:47:35 PM
Quote from: KingsGM
...
 grizzlies got lucky again IMO
...


WRONG !
That is no luck, that is simply good negotiating. You don't make deals with luck ! And that's what you have to learn to get a good GM.


 :shock:
What I don't understand though, how does anyone doing trades with our "hardliner" GMs really believe he'll do a good trade ? Is there an extra bonus involved we don't know about (like you get the best chick at my champ'ship party)? I really need to find answers here ...   :roll: :wink:


Title: Magic-Memphis - Waiting 41
Post by: BullsGM-old on June 01, 2005, 05:43:04 PM
Quote from: KingsGM
it seems like magicGM is making a hard push for the oldest starting five in the league...that's just stupid move, trading away 26 year old star for the 30 year old guard with bad defense and horrible contract.

 grizzlies got lucky again IMO

p.s. but that wont be enough against the Kings of the league :)  :wink:


My god, since when are you a geezer when you turn 30???  Allen was a monster last year and the Magic got some good defenders to surround him by.


Title: Magic-Memphis - Waiting 41
Post by: CelticsGM on June 01, 2005, 05:51:42 PM
Quote from: BullsGM
Quote from: KingsGM
it seems like magicGM is making a hard push for the oldest starting five in the league...that's just stupid move, trading away 26 year old star for the 30 year old guard with bad defense and horrible contract.

 grizzlies got lucky again IMO

p.s. but that wont be enough against the Kings of the league :)  :wink:


My god, since when are you a geezer when you turn 30???  Allen was a monster last year and the Magic got some good defenders to surround him by.

He has a HUGE contract until he's 35, that's the problem


Title: Magic-Memphis - Waiting 41
Post by: KingsGM-old on June 01, 2005, 06:00:10 PM
i second that...

heh, maybe the bullsGM is 30 year old? :D


Title: Magic-Memphis - Waiting 41
Post by: BullsGM-old on June 01, 2005, 06:03:48 PM
Quote from: CelticsGM
Quote from: BullsGM
Quote from: KingsGM
it seems like magicGM is making a hard push for the oldest starting five in the league...that's just stupid move, trading away 26 year old star for the 30 year old guard with bad defense and horrible contract.

 grizzlies got lucky again IMO

p.s. but that wont be enough against the Kings of the league :)  :wink:


My god, since when are you a geezer when you turn 30???  Allen was a monster last year and the Magic got some good defenders to surround him by.

He has a HUGE contract until he's 35, that's the problem


Yeah, big time players have big time contracts, its sort of how it works...  :)

But seriously people are making to much of his contract.  Last year he averaged 31/7/5 (albeit only in half the games).  This year his shooting is down, probably because of the system he's playing in.  He'll fit in nicely with Kidd, who makes up for Allens C+ defense.  

And btw, I'm wondering, whats a measure of good defense?  Allen has C+ defense and is getting the same number of steals as James.  I'm not saying Allen is a better defender then James, but I'm wondering what people go by when they say someone is a bad defender.  Same thing with Billups who is averaging 2 SPG but people say he can't play D


Title: Magic-Memphis - Waiting 41
Post by: BullsGM-old on June 01, 2005, 06:04:54 PM
Quote from: KingsGM
i second that...

heh, maybe the bullsGM is 30 year old? :D


Nah, I'm probably one of the youngest dudes here, just turned 18


Title: old
Post by: GrizzliesGM on June 01, 2005, 06:20:37 PM
Youngest you said, I'm 17.


Title: Magic-Memphis - Waiting 41
Post by: KingsGM-old on June 01, 2005, 06:33:31 PM
geez, i could be your dad, i'm turning 27 for 3 months :)


Title: Magic-Memphis - Waiting 41
Post by: NetsGM on June 01, 2005, 06:49:20 PM
Quote
He has a HUGE contract until he's 35, that's the problem


that's what people said when the Suns (real life) signed Nash.


Title: Magic-Memphis - Waiting 41
Post by: KingsGM-old on June 01, 2005, 06:56:59 PM
well we shall see about that...it helps in short term, but in along run...well that's another story...


Title: Magic-Memphis - Waiting 41
Post by: KingsGM-old on June 01, 2005, 07:01:59 PM
and second, the suns (real suns i mean) didn't trade a 26 year old star for nash...


Title: Magic-Memphis - Waiting 41
Post by: BullsGM-old on June 01, 2005, 07:12:40 PM
Quote from: KingsGM
and second, the suns (real suns i mean) didn't trade a 26 year old star for nash...


Bottom line Allen > Lewis

Thats just my opinion, but I'd take a player who averaged 31/6/5 last year over Lewis.


Title: Magic-Memphis - Waiting 41
Post by: KingsGM-old on June 01, 2005, 07:20:54 PM
it all a matter of goals. if you have a chance at the title, yeah you should go after ray,  but if you're somewhere in the middle (like orlando this year) it's a shortsighted move that will screw all your chances in free agency in the years to come. i would understand this if the mavs did it or some other team that's missing the final piece, but not the magic. they are not contenders (off course i might be wrong) and this move only hurt their chances in the future.  and btw magicGM is already shopping ray...


Title: Magic-Memphis - Waiting 41
Post by: BullsGM-old on June 01, 2005, 07:26:52 PM
Quote from: KingsGM
it all a matter of goals. if you have a chance at the title, yeah you should go after ray,  but if you're somewhere in the middle (like orlando this year) it's a shortsighted move that will screw all your chances in free agency in the years to come. i would understand this if the mavs did it or some other team that's missing the final piece, but not the magic. they are not contenders (off course i might be wrong) and this move only hurt their chances in the future.  and btw magicGM is already shopping ray...


Yeah I always found it odd when a team gets a player and immediately puts him on the block.  That said a team could always improve, so I could sorta understand shopping Ray already


Title: Magic-Memphis - Waiting 41
Post by: MagicGM on June 01, 2005, 10:07:49 PM
the fact with Lewis is did he has not improved even a single rating on training camp..

while for Allen, I do expect that when his contract goes to around the 14million territory, his average will still be around 20-22ppg. IMO..

and no, I'm not going for the oldest lineup.

As for being over the cap for years, Lewis and Allen's contract has the same length and amount.